- M. Amundsen (pen.) 2'
- G. Tapia (pen.) 3'
- A. Herrera (pen.) 4'
- T. Baumgartl (pen.) 1'
- L. MacNaughton (pen.) 2'
- C. Durkin (pen.) 3'
- D. Downs (pen.) 4'
- D. Edelman (pen.) 5'
HT 0–0
- 1'⚽ T. Baumgartl (pen.) (0 - 1)
- 2'⚽ L. MacNaughton (pen.) (0 - 2)
- 2'⚽ M. Amundsen (pen.) (1 - 2)
- 3'⚽ C. Durkin (pen.) (1 - 3)
- 3'⚽ G. Tapia (pen.) (2 - 3)
- 4'⚽ D. Downs (pen.) (2 - 4)
- 4'⚽ A. Herrera (pen.) (3 - 4)
- 5'⚽ D. Edelman (pen.) (3 - 5)
- 68'🔄 G. Tapia↓ J. Martinez
- 78'🔄 B. Lundt↓ R. Burki
- 78'🔄 D. Downs↓ S. Jeong
- 82'🟨 S. Rodriguez
- 84'🔄 S. Bangoura↓ D. Chambost
- 84'🔄 B. Lennon↓ M. Farsi
- 90+1'🔄 E. Bailly↓ T. Habroune
- 90+10'🟨 C. Holse
- 90+12'🟨 D. Downs
- 104'🟨 T. Totland
- 105'🔄 T. Ostrak↓ S. Becher
- 113'🔄 A. Herrera↓ A. Zaroury
- 119'🟨 E. Bailly
Full match
- 5Corners2
- 0Throw In0
- 0Free Kick0
- 0Goal Kick0
- 0Penalty0
- 5Substitution3
- 50%Ball Possession50%
1st half
- 5Corners2
- 0Throw In0
- 0Free Kick0
- 0Goal Kick0
- 0Penalty0
- 4Substitution3
- 107Attacks109
- 65Dangerous Attacks41
- 3On Target4
- 12Off Target1
- 48%Ball Possession52%
Columbus Crew vs St. Louis City in US Open Cup - Final on Thu, Oct 22, 2026.